|
When visa restrictions prevented the president of the University
of Tehran from visiting UC Davis, Chancellor Larry Vanderhoef decided to take UC
Davis to Iran in an effort to reestablish student and scholar exchanges and to
promote cultural understanding.
Told they were the first U.S. university delegation permitted to
visit Iran since that country's 1979 revolution, the UC Davis travelers met with
representatives of four universities, with alumni and friends of the campus, and
with Iran President Mohammed Khatami's Parliament-member brother.
Joining Vanderhoef on this April 25-May 1 trip were Sacramento
businessman and UC Davis Foundation board member Mohammad Mohanna, Dean of the
College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Neal Van Alfen, Dean of the
College of Engineering Enrique Lavernia, Vice Provost for University Outreach
and International Programs William Lacy, and Director of the International
Alumni and Visitors Program Robert Kerr.
Calling the trip "a fruitful first step," the group is exploring
ways to ease visa restrictions, a "2 and 2 program" that would permit Iranian
students to study the first two years at their home university and the next two
years at UC Davis, possible research collaborations and student exchanges, and
the creation of an alumni chapter.
During his visit to Iran, the chancellor kept a journal of
his experience which follows here.
UC Davis
Chancellor Larry Vanderhoef: Iran Journal, April 25-May 1,
2004
Sunday, April 25,
2004: We're On Our Way Well, we're off, setting out for the San Francisco
Airport on the first leg of our 24-hour journey to Tehran.
We carry the
concerns of our families and colleagues who fear for our safety and the
disapproval of some who worry about any possible political fall-out of visiting
what has been deemed by President Bush an "Axis of Evil" country.
We've
talked at length among ourselves and with others about the wisdom of our trip,
about whether our goals outweigh any risk we may be assuming in traveling to the
Middle East right now. We remain convinced we should go, that our desire to
reestablish academic ties, to reopen the free exchange of students and scholars
and to further cultural understanding overrides our concerns. Our conversations
with our Iranian hosts and with the U.S. state department provide us with
sufficient reassurance of a safe trip.
Our journey actually began nearly
five years ago, when fellow traveler Moe Mohanna (a Sacramento businessman and
current member of the UC Davis Foundation Board) hosted an event to raise
scholarship funds for Iranian-American students. That gathering eventually led
to an invitation to the president of the University of Tehran to visit UC Davis;
but when he attempted that trip in 2002, he was denied a visa. So we decided
then that we would take UC Davis to Iran.
So here we are, all six of us
(Moe Mohanna; Neal Van Alfen, dean of the College of Agricultural and
Environmental Sciences; Enrique Lavernia, dean of the College of Engineering;
Bill Lacy, vice provost for university outreach and international programs; Bob
Kerr, director of international alumni and visitors; and me), unsure what we'll
experience this next week but eager to begin a dialogue. We're not going to Iran
to make a political statement, nor are we seeking publicity. We're simply one
university wanting to talk to another university about ways in which we can work
together. And, perhaps in the process, one small step can be taken toward a
return to normalcy in the Middle East.
Sunday, April 25:
Taking flight Once we arrive at the Lufthansa gate area, our concern
about journeying to Iran dissipates. In fact, our fears seem to be left behind
in the U.S. Enrique wonders if the only time there might be a problem with
trips to the Middle East is if one asks about the laws and rules, as we did.
Neal mentions that some of our faculty are planning to attend an international
conference in Iran next year - organized from another country, with individuals
coming from all over the world.
Neal also mentions that our California
crops are much the same as Iran's, and that many of our 250 specialty crops
originated in Iran and other parts of the Middle East thousands of years ago.
Pistachios, for example, came to California some 80 years ago by way of Iran.
With similar climates and irrigation and sustainability challenges, we've much
to learn from each other.
As we taxi down the runway, the plane suddenly
screeches to a halt. We hear another plane land or take off nearby. Our plane
resumes its taxiing, but more slowly this time. I immediately think of some of
the troubling e-mails we'd received since pre-trip stories appeared in our local
newspapers. But then off we fly.
 Iranian population is
remarkably young- half under the age of
20 and 70 percent under 30. Boys and girls, and men and
women, gatherseparately in public.
Monday, April 26:
Mid-way there We land in Frankfurt without incident and make our way to
the hotel for about four hours sleep before returning to the airport for the
next leg of the trip to Tehran. I end up sitting next to an Iranian-American
woman who's from Davis, used to work for UC Davis and has a daughter working at
UC Irvine - the proverbial small world. She's returning to Iran for the one-year
anniversary of her mother's death.
Tuesday, April 27:
At last, we arrive We touch down in Tehran and are greeted at the end of
the jet way by the director general of the University of Tehran's Office of
International Relations and by the university's chief of protocol, who is also
with the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology. While we wait for our
luggage, we chat a bit with our two hosts. Mohammad wears a black shirt under
his suit coat - a sign his father has recently died. He will wear this shirt for
40 days without shaving. Both when his father died, and at the 40-day mourning
mark, he will host a lunch for friends of his father. He served 900 lunches that
first day and expects to do the same 40 days hence. And, on the one-year
anniversary, there'll be another recognition of his father's death.
We
see occasional armed soldiers, but certainly no more than we have seen in other
countries - especially, for example, Taiwan but also South Korea.
We
arrive at our hotel at 4 a.m. but find our rooms aren't ready. After phone calls
home, we're soon to bed, anticipating our visits later today with the president
of the University of Tehran and its engineering faculty.
After four hours
sleep and a breakfast buffet featuring sausage and olives, we head to the
Central Library and Document Center at the University of Tehran. We primarily
spend our time in the section of the library dedicated to saving old books for
future readers ("old" here means up to 1,400 years old).
We then meet
the president of the University of Tehran, Faraji-Dana, for lunch. He's a very
impressive 45-year-old, much interested in any relationships we might build. He
notes his university is pursuing a "2 and 2" exchange program with Indiana
University/Purdue University in Indianapolis and also a one-person plant
taxonomy exchange with UC Berkeley. We have to find out more about
both.
The afternoon is devoted to meetings with the engineering faculty.
It's very clear the trade embargo has made it difficult for them to buy new
equipment or to obtain replacement parts. The embargo's effect shows up on the
streets, as well, where cars are mostly pre-1979. Occasionally, though, their
laboratory equipment was state-of-the-art, likely purchased through other
countries.
President Faraji and I talk again that evening. He's very much
wanting to establish collaborative ties and hopes those ties will expand to
other universities.
He also expresses puzzlement that his country rather
than Saudi Arabia has been so heavily targeted by the U.S. - particularly
because Saudi Arabia spawned the majority of those associated with the September
11, 2001 attack. The relationship between our two countries is certainly
complicated and challenging, from the 1979 revolution and overthrow of the shah,
the hostage-taking at our embassy and our support of Iraq and Saddam Hussein
during the eight-year Iran-Iraq War - a war that stopped, as Moe Mohanna says,
because the people of both countries just got tired of war. After that war, it
was quite clear to Iran they had no aid or support.
We talk as well
about how Iran's left-leaning potential candidates for parliament have been
eased out of the opportunity to run by the Supreme Council - the country's 12
highest-ranking ayatollahs, who are responsible for keeping the government's
actions within the constraints of Islam. So the government will ease back toward
the right after the next election and the country's president will finish his
second term and be unable to run again. It's interesting that the people here
are not expecting any of these changes to be huge or unusual, but simply the
result of a government that will shift, as all governments do, but in this case
toward the right by selection and support of right-leaning candidates.
We
end the day at a dinner gathering of some 80 people with connections to UC
Davis, including the deputy minister of agriculture, who is an alum. The dinner
features traditional chicken/lamb kabobs and a superb mushroom soup that I could
make a whole meal of. We exchange gifts and listen to traditional Iranian music
drawn from ancient mystic writings - it's beautiful, quite unique to the Middle
East.
 The shah's
summer palace grounds- once reserved for Iran's elite-are now enjoyed by
everyday Iranians.
Wednesday, April
28: Off to more visits We're off to visit the University of Tehran's
agriculture faculty this morning. The dean (a very funny, interesting guy) wants
us to visit every department, but that just isn't possible - though we manage to
cover a lot of ground before lunch.
We split up in the afternoon, with
Neal, Bill and Bob staying to talk further with the ag faculty, while Moe,
Enrique and I visit a brand-new hospital built by the Rahimians (the family,
with roots in Iran, also extends to Sacramento and has sent two sons to UC
Davis). The hospital was built in an area of relatively poor people without easy
access to medical care. A while back, the Rahimian family also built a high
school for girls, with about 1,000 now enrolled.
On the way to the
hospital, it feels as if one of the wheels of our car suddenly goes badly, badly
out of balance. As luck would have it, a tow truck just happens by and we are
quickly fetched by Laudan Rahimian, sister of Majid Rahimian. Before we leave,
we take an outdoor picture with most of the nurses on duty. For the second time,
I make the cultural mistake of attempting to shake the hand of one of them to
whom we have given a UC Davis pen. When I first met Laudan, she put her hand out
to make it clear that, in her case, she would recognize our
custom.
Laudan's husband drives us back to our hotel at breakneck speeds
- up to 165 kilometers an hour (I haven't done the conversion, but it's close to
100 miles per hour) on a freeway where most people are going 65 miles per hour.
The lane markers on these highways are not much more than suggestions, with
often four lanes of traffic squeezed into three marked lanes. It's just the
normal way of things, but if you're not used to it, it's very worrisome. More
than a couple of times, Enrique and I simultaneously yell something like "watch
out" (or an internationally understood equivalent).
At 8:30 p.m. we
depart for the parliament and dinner with the brother of President Khatami. Our
conversation has many pregnant pauses; the three individuals with Khatami don't
speak at all. But after dinner, we go outside to have tea. Khatami and I talk
lots about his predictions for the future of universities, why he thinks Iran is
viewed so negatively by the U.S., why any kind of "revolution" by students now
would be completely different from the one in 1979 (they're more educated now,
he says, and have a better realization of what can and can't be accomplished by
the overthrow of any government). He recognizes that, in this stage of Iran's
evolution, theocracy is most likely to work but that it might not be the form of
government that would necessarily serve well in the future. He feels very
strongly there are not many ways to break down the stereotype that people in the
world have of Iran, but believes the "university track" is a way that could be
successful.
Thursday, April 29:
On to the 'Cal Tech of Iran' After a breakfast of eggs, cold meats,
cheeses, coffee, juices, milk and cold cereals, we set out for Sharif University
of Technology - the Cal Tech of Iran. While women are as prevalent in Iranian
universities as men (in fact, women slightly outnumber men), only about 30
percent of the students at technology universities are female (just as in the
U.S.).
The university's president also expresses frustration that Iran
has been singled out as part of the "Axis of Evil." He points to the culture,
traditions and history of Persia (primarily Iran, he says, but also Armenia and
Turkey) as different from Arab countries. Those countries do not share the
ancient history and culture of Iran, the birthplace of most history and culture
in the world, he says. Neither do Iranians support Al-Queda or the Taliban, he
says. Mostly it's peace that's desired and a fair understanding of each other,
he says.
After lunch, we depart for Isfahan and visits to two
universities. From the air, we see essentially a salt plain; as we near the
city, we see irrigated crops and mud adobe-type construction. The towns outside
Isfahan look very poor; the city itself seems an oasis of trees, grass and
flowers.
The hotel is very nice (much nicer than the buildings around
it), with televisions with perhaps 12 channels - most in Farsi, with soccer
matches, an occasional NBA basketball game, "tame" American movies, one or two
German-language channels, and BBC and CNN. We see pictures of the bombing of
Fallujah on Iranian channels and on BBC and CNN. We're not getting a good
review.
Dinner's with several alumni - including one who has an interest
in the travel industry and has moved to Iran to be ready when it once again
becomes an important destination. Another has gone into the business of
university-related research parks there.
Our evening ends with a stroll
at the ancient "lighted bridges" (one is 280 years old, another 480 years old).
Groups of young people stop and sing under their arches, to the applause of
others nearby.
Friday, April 30: A
marathon day Today will be a very, very long day. We will not go to bed
again until we are home.
Ahead are visits to the University of Isfahan
(its president is a UC Riverside grad) and Isfahan University of Technology (its
president is a UC Berkeley grad), as well as some sightseeing, and then a flight
back to Tehran for an alumni/going-away gathering.
As we walk the city
streets, unaccompanied by our hosts, we are treated warmly and graciously by
adults and with curiosity and respect by children. We are struck with how young
the population is - 50 percent under the age of 20 and 70 percent under 30. The
teenagers are fun and engaging but sometimes very solemnly forthright. I will
never forget, to the day I die, a young girl asking me, "Do you think we are all
terrorists?" Other young people ask how they can come to America and eagerly
accept our business cards.
We visit mosques, bazaars, palaces and a
Christian church and enjoy our conversations. We see that men and women rarely
mix, at least publicly - and that women are covered except for their faces, with
some younger women wearing blue jeans as slacks and also makeup.
At an
alumni gathering that evening at the Rahimians' home, we meet with about 40
people with UC ties. All of the alums we've met this trip are proud of their
alma maters and treasure their memories of their time in the U.S. They want
their children to have the same opportunities they had, and are excellent
ambassadors for American universities and for America, generally. They want, as
well, for other Iranians to see America as they saw it and not as we've also
been negatively represented in the media around the world.
We depart the
party long after midnight and head to the airport for a 3:05 a.m. flight
home.
Saturday, May 1:
Heading home/Next steps We use our Frankfort layover time to try to
assess what we've experienced and to see possible next steps in forging a
relationship with the Iranian universities we've visited.
We're all
struck with the high quality of the faculty and students - their admissions
standards, in fact, are tougher than UC's. Graduate study there is all done in
English, and passing an English exam is part of the admissions process.
While this trip is a fruitful first step, we recognize the considerable
challenges that lie ahead.
Perhaps the biggest is the current severe visa
restrictions that make it virtually impossible for Iranians to travel to this
country.
But one potential exchange possibility is the "2 and 2" program,
where Iranian students would spend the first two years at their home university
taking courses approved by UC and then come to America, to UC Davis, for the
remaining two years of their program - giving us a bit more time to resolve the
visa problem.
Another possibility is sending our students there, perhaps
for summer study.
A third possibility would involve exchange of scholars
based on real needs they have and we have - truly a two-way street.
And
perhaps, as well, we can establish a formal alumni chapter in Iran to help us
recruit outstanding students, host visiting students and scholars and provide
internship opportunities.
After nearly 22 hours in the air and another
two hours on California's Interstate 80, we arrive home tired but energized. In
this initial visit, we didn't sign agreements or contracts with our Iranian
colleagues, but we sat together, we ate together, we discussed our separate
countries and cultures together, and we came to better understand our
universities, our similarities and differences, and our shared interest in a
community of scholars without borders. I hope our trip moves us a step closer
and, in the words of Sen. J. William Fulbright, in some small way helps "turn
nations into people."
... Payvand News - 12/8/04 ... --
|