By Mali Mostoufi, New York
"I went to the gambling-house, witnessed all the losers, but honest and sincere
When I came to this temple, all hypocritical-devouts." [1]
Mohammad Ghazalli
This famous French proverb, "People are the way(s) that
they are" gnaws at my mind. Are we that immutable as
hard rocks?... Can we not change ourselves for better?...`
I have in mind those educated, worldly intelligent individuals
in the Iranian society and outside their Motherland and NOT
the unfortunate ignorants. Those who have vast personal
and sociological experiences, are well-read, have profound
knowledge in most fields of Sciences, History, Arts and
Literature, etc., etc.,... but underneath those massive 'wealth'
harbor, to put it mildly, their not so healthy characteristic
minds and psychs. Their obsessiveness, jealousy,
meanness, stinginess, especially their emotional stinginess,
their deep sense of unhealthy rivalry are hidden under that
wealth of knowledge. And yes, wealth is a cover for most of
human's faults. But for how long?...
They hurt their society more than and worse than any other
internal and external enemies, and in the long run they will
be exposed and are hurt themselves.
Our history is full of these characters. Hence, and mostly
by our great poets, they are named or labeled as hypocrites,
demagogues, individuals with thousand faces.
In modern times it is much easier and faster to recognize
such 'intelligentsia.' How long did it take time, for example,
to know who the real Ahmed Challabi, or Fowad Ajami who
actually has published books and articles here and there, is
the head of a department in a university here, to be exposed and
known as hypocrites, cheaters, liars and sold-souls?... Well,
believe me they are highly educated and 'intelligent.' So are
their likes or their counterparts inside and outside Iran. And
in the end they all loose their believers, their friends and
acquaintances and worse, their respect in their societies and
in the world.
Do they wonder why?... I wonder!... I hope they do. They
surely blame 'others' rather than themselves. Perhaps
it is because they are "hard rocks" and immutable. I name
them "arrogant blinds" who never wish to look at themselves
in the fast revealing mirror of history. They throw dusts at it and
see only dust. And they project their own dusts on everyone
who sees and exposes their-real-selves.
These dusty-minded types if even ask 'why', but they do not
want or are afraid to examine some of those massive dusts
which have covered their mirrors. Their mirrors are road to
their salvation, their cure. They don't want to see WHY "they
are the way they are." They are proud of it.
It is such a shame when the so known as "Healers" for inside
and outside Iran are sick themselves. "How a bunch of rotten
salt can preserve something else from rotting ?..."
Then, "what is to be done?"--this famous question of Lenin.
I am afraid the answer lies on the conscious of those types, the
"wealthy Intellectuals" that I am addressing in this short article:
1)- To look and see inside, underneath their 'Wealthy knowledge.'
2)- What are there?... Monsters?...
3)- Face them and admit to themselves that these are their
enemies and not "others" outside them.
4)- Change, change and Change: to better themselves.
Iranian society can no longer afford to harbor sick healers
with sick-deeds who cloak their behaviors by beautifully
superficial utterances. Too many thieves have come to Our
Homeland and have stolen the best we had here throughout
the Persian History. Arabs, Turks, Moguls, Tattars, They came
though with swords but also wit 'beautiful' utterances too which
have become like our second nature. No wonder that today
we have become, as the Persian proverb goes, " The pottage
hotter than the Pot."
Nothing is immutable in this world. We must change our ways
of thinking, our bad habits and deeds and change for better.
Otherwise we shall remain in the vast prison of all the inside and
outside demagogues longer than fourteen hundred years.
Only us and us only can save us from that prison which for
such a long history we are addicted to stay in and seek some
other Saviors. How could those Thorn-Crowned-Saviors be
our Salvagers who were and are just Pretenders?
Are we going to re-read the history and those "sacred books"
with open minds and critically without fanaticism and
without superstitious and mostly without fear?
Let us become realistic in this modern Twenty-first Century.
The so many bloody wars and revolutions did not make of us
a realistic Nation. Indeed after each era we curled back to
our 'safe' spots and took refuge into our many-fold-
monasteries (Khaneghah). There we were served better to
look other way than to this Real World that we live in. Such
beautiful illusions. Every scientific revolution that shook
other places and nations we remained in the happy illusional
world of our minds, until we became hands-out beggars for
the need of all sciences. Those very few who realized our
county's poverty and started to alert the people were labeled
as "Westomaniacs" and we parroted all the words uttered by
our psuedo-intellectuals.
The rest is this quarter century that like an everlasting
nightmare has fallen on our country and on our nation.
It is a revolution in our minds that we need to bring forth.
Or are we still immutable?...
[1] under the two verse-poem (by Ghazalli) : A free translation
of two verses. M. M.