(Published in hardback under the
title Persian Pilgrimages)
Frank Foer of the
New Republic wrote a fine book, How Soccer
Explains the World. In it, he referred to
Iran's "football revolution," the
moment in 1997 when some 5,000 Iranian women defied a ban on entering the
stadium, and literally stormed the gates to join 120,000 screaming men in
celebration of Iran's just-returned soccer stars, who
had qualified for the World Cup. Foer sensed an important marker in Iranian
history, one that led to a series of more soccer-related political
demonstrations over the next few years.

order from
amazon
When
Iran defeated the
United
States in a World Cup soccer match in
1998, the country exploded in celebration and the Islamic Republic found itself
in a bind. "The Great Satan" had been defeated, but the popular celebrations on
that night challenged hard-line government orthodoxy. Women danced with men in
public, people threw firecrackers at the police, and many chanted slogans
against regime hard-liners.
Often after big matches, young
men-unemployed and angry-vandalize government property while chanting crude
slogans about the opposing team and, occasionally, their own leaders. In 2001, a
few thousand Iranians, incensed by rumors that the team purposefully lost a key
World Cup qualifying game by government order, clashed with police while
chanting antigovernment slogans. Though the rumor-fueled by Diaspora television
stations-is unlikely to be true, the national team displayed a striking
inability to beat lesser teams during the qualifying stretch and failed to make
the 2002 Cup.
In a sense, the team's soccer
malaise mirrored the country's political malaise, as hard-liners tightened their
grip on power and the country's reformists took a beating without much of a
fight.
In October 2004, I decided to head
for Azadi (Freedom) Stadium to watch the Iran-Germany exhibition match. That
night, I saw not so much a "football revolution", but an array of experiences
that provided a metaphor for the contemporary Iranian predicament, and clues to
the country's future.
I went to the stadium with my friend
Hossein, a veteran of the 1980-88 Iran-Iraq war, his brother Hassan and two of
his sons, and Karim Sadjadpour, an Iranian-American Tehran-based analyst with
the International Crisis Group who is, in my estimation, the best of a new
generation of Iran analysts because he combines analytic rigor with a big
heart.
We met at Hassan's small grocery
shop and piled into his car. Hassan, unlike Hossein, chose not to fight in the
war with Iraq. While Hossein displays a picture
of Ayatollah Khomeini in his modest home, Hassan prefers the late Shah. Hassan
originally cheered the revolution, but he has grown weary of
Iran's clerical rulers and openly
ridicules them in family gatherings - a source of tension between the two
brothers. He also watches Persian-language satellite television programs from
Los
Angeles, and sings the praises of the late
Shah. "God rest his soul," he often tells me, as Hossein looks on with barely
concealed disgust. Whenever I see Hassan, he regales me with profanity-laced
jokes.
Hassan has done well for himself. He
co-owns a small grocery, invests in real estate, and dabbles in manufacturing.
Occasionally, he even travels to Germany to attend trade shows and, as he
says, "drink my whiskey in peace."
These two brothers, hailing from the
same religious working-class background, reflect the myriad ways the revolution
has shaped what Khomeini called the mostazafin (oppressed masses). Hassan
once told me, "I grew up very religious. When I was a kid, my father always told
me to say hello to the local mullah. Today, I steer my kids away from them."
Hossein, to whom I was closer, would often take me aside after our meetings with
Hassan and say: "Don't listen to him. He has lost his way."
On the drive to the stadium, Hassan
cursed and joked and laughed his way through the chaotic traffic. Young men
leaned out of car windows blowing on horns and chanting
"Iran!
Iran!
Iran!"
We parked in a distant lot, and
joined the waves of Iranian men-mostly young-excitedly marching toward the
stadium. At the entrance to the stadium, we joined the melee of chaotic pushing
and shoving with no line in sight. We squirmed our way toward the front, holding
Hassan's young sons' hands tightly, elbowing people in the process, finally
making it inside the stadium grounds.
Once inside, several doors to the
arena were blocked by police. Young men swarmed the grounds, laughing and
yelling and cursing and banging on drums and blowing on
horns.
"What the hell is going on here?"
someone screamed. "Why won't they let us in?"
Suddenly, a rumor spread that the
east gate was opening. Hundreds of young men sprinted east, banging on drums,
some with flags draped on their backs like superheroes.
Hossein instructed us to stay in
line. A uniformed security officer approached our gates. A group of young men in
beards-members of the Basijis-sauntered to the front of the line, shook hands
with the officers, and passed through the gate. The crowd roared its disapproval
with a few choice epithets aimed at the Basijis and their mothers. Hossein, a
Basiji himself, frowned his disapproval. I wasn't sure if he was upset with the
insults or the actions of his colleagues.
Finally, the gates flew open and we
stampeded into the stadium, still clutching the boys by the hands. Wrestling our
way into a few empty seats, we sat down, an hour before kickoff, near the front
rows, a crisp green soccer field before us and a hundred thousand excited
(mostly young) Iranians around us.
Large loudspeakers on the grass
blasted carefully mixed government-approved techno music. The crowd swayed to
the beat. A small group near us banged on drums. I looked around to see if I
could spot German women in the VIP sections-foreign women are allowed
prescreened entry to the stadium.
When Karim turned to take pictures,
young men swarmed around us, flashing the V sign. As he snapped photos, the
techno music stopped, and the loudspeaker recited verses from the Quran. Most
people chatted and ignored it, as Iranians often do when presented with
"official Islam." The music roared back on, and the crowd
cheered.
Shortly before the game began, an
unctuous sounding voice urged the crowd to stand for "the national anthem of the
Islamic Republic of Iran."
Most Iranians I know prefer the
prerevolution anthem suffused with nationalist themes. Even Hossein says he
likes the prerevolution one better. For many years, the anthem was banned, but
on this day, in the soccer stadium, a truncated version of it (without lyrics)
was played after the Islamic Republic anthem. The crowd's reaction was more
deferential to this anthem, but not overly excited either.
A wandering vendor sold ice cream
bars. Another, a gaptoothed elderly man with wizened skin, offered hot
tea.
When the German team trotted onto
the field, the Iranian fans gave them a rousing ovation. Hassan turned to me,
and said, "If this was an Arab team, you would have heard some great insults,
but we respect the Germans."
As the Iranian team made their way
to the field, a deafening roar rocked the stadium. Flags waved. Feet stomped.
Arms raised.
All of the team's players were
clean-shaven. Nearly all of the team's officials wore beards. In a sense, the
razor blade gave the team a populist air. They are one of "us," Iranians could
feel, not one of "them," the government-types with their Nehru-collar shirts and
close-cropped beards. Several of the players had even become teen heartthrobs,
with the long hair and floppy bangs of pop singers.
On the stadium periphery, I saw
advertisements for Samsung, Hyundai, and Emirates airlines-all major
international companies that prize the Iranian market , signs that Iranian trade
relations are growing, despite U.
S. sanctions.
An announcer spoke throughout the
warm-ups, urging the crowd to welcome the German team (which they already had
done) and cheer loudly for "the national team of the Islamic Republic of Iran,"
elongating the words "Jomhurieyeh-e-Eslami- e- Iran" in that annoying, contrived
stadium announcer voice heard around the world. Every time the crowd chanted,
they would simply cry "Iran!" They never bothered to
incorporate the "Islamic Republic" part in any of their ingenious
chants.

The German team deflated the crowd
early with a quick goal, but the Iranian squad held its own, narrowly missing
two prime goal opportunities. At halftime, with
Iran down 1-0, the chairman of the
German football federation walked onto the field accompanied by several smiling,
bearded officials of the Islamic Republic. He presented a check to the mayor of
Bam to help that earthquake-devastated city with reconstruction.
Several people around me cracked
jokes. "That will help the mayor pay for his new Benz." (The Bam earthquake
relief has been riddled with government corruption.)
After the ceremony, a pop singer
appeared, introduced by the announcer in English as "one of the pop music people
of the Islamic Republic of Iran." His mild pop failed to excite the crowd, who
mostly talked and continued banging on drums and waving flags and chanting
"Eee-ran!"
In the second half, the team once
again missed several scoring opportunities, ultimately losing 2-0. A few minutes
before the game ended, we made our way to the exits amid more drum banging and
flag waving.
Once we located our car in the vast
parking lot, we were told to pay a fee, which sparked a heated exchange between
Hassan and the attendant. "You are killing us with your fees!" he said "Don't
the mullahs have enough money!" He muttered a few more insults under his breath,
involving mullahs and female body parts.
Snaking through the traffic, young
men on motorbikes continued to wave the Iranian flag. Chants of
"Iran!
Iran!
Iran!" broke out spontaneously. The
crowd remained of good cheer. After all, the match had no bearing on
Iran's World Cup status.
In March 2005, after a 2-1 victory
over Japan that catapulted
Iran into first place in the Asian
qualifiers, fans went on a joyful rampage, damaging some eighty buses and
reportedly chanting anti-regime slogans. On this night, however, the most
dramatic moments came as Hassan darted his car in and out of the traffic and
pedestrians and motorbikes that all spilled onto the same
road.
Later that night, I reflected on my
night at the soccer stadium, which, I thought, provided a metaphor for the
contemporary Iranian predicament. I saw frustrated young men and official
mismanagement. I saw raw nationalism and barely concealed contempt for
government officials. I saw the government's schizophrenia- officially
prescribed techno music, a halftime pop music concert, and Quranic verses
interspersed throughout. I also saw small attempts by government to reclaim its
nationalist credentials (the playing of the prerevolution anthem) and clumsy
attempts to reach out to youth: again, the pop star.
The traffic was bad, the stadium was
creaking, and the whole affair had a Third World air of chaos to it, but, at the
end of the day, most people made it home safely that night. There were no riots,
no serious injuries. Somehow, it all worked, though egos were bruised and minor
injuries were sustained.
Still, the threat of disorder lurked
in the air. Twenty-six years after the revolution, the Islamic Republic creaks
along despite its many faults, bruising its people along the way, even as the
threat of disorder remains in the background. This begs the question: Will the
"football revolution"-the model of determined Iranians demanding their rights by
storming the gates, as in 1997-be emulated on a larger scale, or will Iran look
something more like my night at the stadium: chaotic and badly managed, with the
threat of disorder in the air, but, ultimately, the state managing to maintain
control through a sophisticated system of carrots and
sticks?
The answer probably lies somewhere
in between. As I left the stadium that night, I could only hope that one day in
the not-too-distant future the soccer stadium known as Azadi (Freedom) will
truly deserve its name.
For more, see www.soulofiran.com