By
Jamshid S.
Irani, Attorney at
Law, New York
On Thursday, June 7, 2007 in the Senate, Majority
Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) temporarily set aside the Comprehensive Immigration
Reform Act, after the bill’s supporters failed to garner enough votes to end
debate and proceed toward a vote on final passage. I dare state that no
Iranian-American cared. Despite this setback, the bill’s “grand bargainers”
continue to work behind the scenes to craft a procedural agreement that could
pave the way for a final round of debate and votes on CIR. If the bargainers
succeed in striking a bipartisan deal, Senator Reid could bring the bill back to
the floor after the Senate dispenses with energy legislation, sometime before
the July 4 recess. President Bush has made a commitment to work harder toward
the passage of the bill which would conclude his 8-year legacy at the White
House. Whether his move is too late in the process remains to
be seen.
Immigration reform
has been a primary domestic policy issue and source of debate over the past 18
months. Like no other subject, our treatment of and need for foreigners is an
emotionally charged topic for most Americans. It is no longer divided along
party lines, religious beliefs or social status: how many aliens can enter, work
and reside in the United States
matters to everyone.
In all of the business
assessments, social services impacts, statistical projections, and enforcement
measures, many see immigrants as one uniform group. As an Iranian-American who
immigrated to the United
States 30 years ago, I am surprised at the
one-sided view. While it is true that 100 years ago,
during the industrial revolution, immigrants were coming to the
U.S. to fill general labor jobs to
improve economic position for themselves and their families, a lot has changed
since then.
Over the past 100
years, political, economic, social and cultural circumstances have changed
dramatically in the U.S. and in other countries.
Americans engaged in the immigration debate, however, seem blind to the
qualities of arriving immigrants. It appears that, when debating the rules of
the admission, residence, and citizenship for new immigrants, everyone focuses
on landscapers, farm workers, factory workers and similar low-skill jobs that
natives typically turn down. It seems that the voices of most immigrants in the
last two decades are silent and indifferent. Certainly, the voices of
Iranian-Americans have been silent.
As an immigration
attorney handling cases nationwide and an immigrant myself, I strongly disagree
with this picture of new immigrants. The vast majority of my clients, and
foreign nationals who I meet around the country, are not economic immigrants. We
came here for upward social mobility, something our native countries failed to
offer. We have gained the basic educational background in Iran and
completed it here.
We are highly educated,
hard-working contributors to American society, the quintessential
super-achievers. Doctors and engineers in Iran or the Philippines, scientists in Canada, Germany or France are
highly-respected and well-paid professionals. It is because we achieved our
goals in our ancestral home and could go no further that we came to the
United
States. Unlike the immigrants who came here 100
years ago for the opportunity to eat, stay warm or simple survival, we came for
success. I should add that many have sought sanctuary here for persecutions at
home.
By recognizing our
strength and providing us with opportunities, the United
States proves again that it is the world's
strongest democracy. In any other non-native country, our accent, race, culture,
or background would delegate us to the bottom of the career ladder. Not in
America. Here, people are recognized
for his or her achievements and potential. There are many successful
Iranian-Americans holding some of the highest positions in various fields.
The mutual embrace
between immigrants and our new-found motherland is stronger and more lasting. We
do not question rules because we grew up with rigid authority. We do not dwell
on set-backs because we know we have a long journey ahead. We grab opportunities
because we waited for them so long. Are we not the citizens that
America should cherish? It is our
contributions that add competitive advantages, economic prosperity and cultural
diversity, the cornerstones of a successful society.
Unless
U.S. laws continue to encourage the
best and the brightest not only to study here, but to stay and contribute, the
best and most driven people will go elsewhere. We are keenly aware of thousands
of American jobs moving overseas. To stop the outflow, America needs to
attract and retain the successful immigrants who create jobs through the money
they spend on child care, investments, homes, cars, services and other economic
drivers. These are the immigrants who should be considered when Americans debate
the final form of our immigration laws.
We, as
Iranian-Americans, have our work cut for us. We must do our share too. We must
get involved and encourage our representative to vote for the legislation and
give it another chance. As President Bush does his share, we, too, should
contact and persuade our representatives to work harder to pass a law which
would include smart border and worksite enforcement; path to earned permanent
residence for the undocumented; a new worker program and finally reunification
of families separated for years and decades. We, Iranian-Americans, are and
should be part of this melting pot and this evolving process. We are and could
more be leaders in communities where we live. But the key to advance remains in
how dedicated we are and how committed we feel toward our obligations to our
society, that is the city, state and country where we live. We,
Iranian-Americans, should treasure our past and look forward in our adopted
land. With 27% for, 33% against and 40% undecided, we could make a big
difference. Let us show it!
Jamshid
S. Irani, Attorney at
Law
1170 Broadway, Suite
510
New
York, NY
10001