Ben Gilbert, VOA, Beirut, Lebanon
The bloody crackdown ordered by President Bashar al-Assad against protesters throughout Syria is having an effect on the nation's economy. International condemnation of the military assaults have prompted trading partners in Europe and elsewhere to hold off on business dealings, and tourists have been scared away.
Nabil Salha lives in a little mountain resort town called
Mashta Helou. The town boasts the best of both worlds: the cool air of the
mountains, and beaches just a short drive away.
Salha usually works as a guide for the flocks of tourists who come to escape the summer heat. But not this year.
"There's no tourism this year," he said, "because for a tourist to reach the resort he needs to drive down a highway with loads of police and army stationed on it."
The police and army are there to clamp down on anti-government protests. Salha says there aren't any problems in his town, which is mainly Christian. But he said in nearby villages and towns there have been clashes between protesters and security forces. So this summer he's gone to Lebanon to stay with his mother.
"We are living without work in Syria," he said. "My father is getting his pension - but it's not much."
Salha says he is losing about $1,000 a month and hasn't worked for three months. He said he is borrowing money from people, and going into debt.
Other Syrians in the tourism industry also are suffering.
Reports suggest hotels in the tourist hubs of Damascus and Aleppo are empty. Tourism makes up about 12 percent of Syria's $52 billion economy.
Hilal Khashan of the American University of Beirut said the the uprising, and the government's refusal to make meaningful reform, have put a serious strain on the economy.
"There's no tourism, no transit. There's a flight of capital from Syria. The economy is not in full gear," said Khashan.
Gulf Arab and foreign companies have delayed or cancelled huge projects in Syria. The stock market there has dropped 41 percent. Economists say the gross domestic product, projected earlier this year to grow at 3 percent, may shrink by 5 percent.
Khashan said the greatest threat now facing the Assad government is not the protests - it's Syria's collapsing economy.
"Those middle class people who have secure jobs and send their kids to school and can afford to go to super market and live fairly decent by Syrian standards will begin to realize the Assad regime has become a liability," said Khashan.
Many of those middle class people live in Aleppo and Damascus, cities that have yet to see significant protests. Khashan said people in those cities have benefited from Assad's economic liberalization, and found stability with the regime, but...
"If the elements of good life they are enjoying seem to be endangered, they may change their minds," said Khashan.
One example came last week. Syrians found that their credit cards stopped working due to U.S. and European sanctions on Syrian banks.
But it's the rural poor who've suffered most under Assad's decade of economic reforms. He cut subsidies on fuel and food, lowered investment in agriculture and cut government jobs. Now in the face of growing unrest, Assad has increased subsidies, and raised wages in the large government bureaucracy.
Syria used to bankroll the subsidies through its oil exports. But those exports are dwindling.
The European Union has been the number one buyer of Syrian oil. Now sanctions could bar EU countries from importing Syrian oil.
Economist Lahcen Achy said sanctions in general could wind up hurting Syria's poor and working classes - the very people who are protesting.
"And the issue is that the effectiveness - it still might take a long time. A regime can survive for a long time. Iran, Iraq, Libya, etc.," he said.
Achy said economic sanctions can only do so much. He said political and diplomatic pressure is the best way to push Assad into enacting real reforms, or stepping down.
Salha, the unemployed tour guide, doubts the tourists will come back to Syria any time soon. And he doesn't see any end in sight.
"I'm afraid from both sides" he said. "If the regime is toppled there will be chaos. And the opposition has no leadership." Salha said "there's no one to take over if Assad leaves." At the same time, he believes that the Syrian president will not make any meaningful reforms that will calm the protesters.
For now, Salha is staying in Lebanon, looking for work as a tour guide here.
Image from amateur video made available by Shamsnn on August 30, 2011 shows protesters carrying a large Syrian flag with the words "Freedom, Syria" written on it in Arabic in Idlib. (The contents of this image cannot be independently verified)
British Foreign Secretary William Hague says EU officials are preparing to discuss sanctions on Syria's oil sector as a way of pressuring Damascus to stop a deadly crackdown on pro-democracy protesters.
Speaking Thursday in Paris, Hague said there is a "real prospect" that EU officials meeting in Poland later this week will agree to ban the sale of Syrian oil to the 27-nation bloc. The European Union and the United States have tightened sanctions against Syria in recent weeks and called for Syrian President Bashar al-Assad to resign for ignoring international appeals to end the crackdown.
Assad's government also appears to have suffered a setback with the first apparent defection of a prominent provincial official to the opposition. The attorney general for the central province of Hama said Thursday in a YouTube video that he has resigned in protest at recent mass killings and arrests of local opposition activists by Syrian security forces.
In the video, Adnan Bakkour accuses pro-Assad forces of killing 72 prisoners in the province on July 31 before imposing a siege on Hama city in August and killing another 420 people for participating in what he called "peaceful" protests. He says government forces buried the dead in mass graves and instructed him to blame the killings on armed gangs.
Syria's state-run SANA news agency says Bakkour was kidnapped earlier this week by "armed terrorist groups" and forced to make his resignation statement under duress. In another video posted to the Internet Thursday, Bakkour denies being kidnapped.
Syrian rights activists and residents say Syrian security forces backed by tanks renewed operations in Hama on Wednesday, hunting for leaders behind the five-month uprising against President Assad and making arrests. Hama has seen some of the country's biggest protests demanding an end to Mr. Assad's 11-year autocratic rule.
Also Wednesday, the British-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said violence linked to the uprising killed 360 civilians and 113 security personnel during the just-ended Muslim holy month of Ramadan.
Some information for this report was provided by AP, AFP and Reuters.
... Payvand News - 09/02/11 ... --