Business & Economy | Energy & Oil Art | Film & Music | Events Heritage & History Philanthropy
Sports | Politics For Peace | Society & Culture Literature & Books Health & Medicine
Rights | Women | Diaspora Travel | Environment & Geography Science & Education Middle East & Asia

Home|News|Archive|RSS
twitter|facebook|Privacy Policy



Payvand Iran News ...
11/17/13 Bookmark and Share
Are Saudi Arabia, Israel Behind France Scuttling Nuclear Talks?


Apartheid | Wahhabism

By Cecily Hilleary, VOA

WASHINGTON, D.C. - Talks between Iran and a group of six Western nations aimed at freezing Iran’s nuclear program are scheduled to resume on November 20th in Geneva. A first round of talks broke down after the so-called P5+1 and Iran failed to agree on a short-term deal that would have eased sanctions on Iran and allowed it to continue low-level enrichment. The US says any eventual deal struck with Iran will be"failsafe" and will guarantee that Iran has no nuclear weapons capability.

Analysts say two issues scuttled the talks; Iran claims it has the right to enrich uranium and wants this acknowledged in writing, and France demands that Iran stop construction on a heavy water reactor at Arak. Meanwhile, observers say “frenemies” Israel and Saudi Arabia are campaigning behind the scenes to make sure Iran’s nuclear program never goes military.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin has been vocal against what he calls "a very bad deal."

“This is a country that is participating as we speak in the mass slaughter of men, women, children, tens of thousands of them in Syria,” he told America’s CBS News recently.

Israeli television reported that a French lawmaker -- and good friend of Netanyahu -- phoned the French Foreign Minister during the Geneva talks, warning him that Netanyahu would attack Iran’s nuclear facilities if the P5+1 nations didn’t push tougher conditions on Iran.

“The chief concern is simply the fact that the Israelis believe that the agreement as it is being shaped will not stop the Iranian nuclear program, but will give the Iranians time to recover from the imposition of the sanctions that may have stifled their economy,” Josef Olmert, a Middle East expert and adjunct professor at the University of South Carolina, said.

Olmert believes opposition boils down to the issue of verification.

“You may recall the big celebrations in 1994 when the Clinton Administration claimed to have reached a similar agreement with North Korea,” Olmert said. “And we know what happened later on. The verification wasn’t there, and the North Koreans are either already having the nuclear bomb or very close to it.”

And he added, “The pro-Israel community in the U.S. is mobilized,” believing President Barack Obama will face heavy pressure from lawmakers to impose further sanctions on Iran until Tehran surrenders all nuclear weapons capability.

Olmert says a deal is inevitable and necessary - but it should not be rushed into.

“There is a sense that somehow the American Administration wants to get rid of all of its nagging problems right now," he said.

Saudi, French and Israeli concerns meet

Saudi Arabia may be less vocal than Israel, but the Kingdom is just as angry over the proposed deal with Iran. Relations between Sunni Saudi Arabia and Shiite Iran are among the most bitter in the region and can be measured by how they react to regional crises-in Syria, Iran backs the Assad regime and Saudi Arabia backs the Sunni rebels. Analysts say the Saudi’s fear Iran is working to undermine Sunni Arab governments in the Gulf. And they fear that if Iran builds nuclear bombs, they will be the first target.

“They don’t believe Iranian protestations that their nuclear program is for civilian purposes. And they are uncertain with the position of the US and are very concerned that the US is going to enter into a bad deal,” said analystSimon Henderson of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.

“And so less noticeably, perhaps, than Bibi Netanyahu, but not invisibly, the Saudis have been very active in lobbying in the absence of the US, where they seem to have given up, they’ve certainly been lobbying the French and, one can assume, the British and other significant groups as well,” he said.

Henderson cites a number of meetings between Saudi and French officials in recent weeks, including a visit to Jeddah by French Defense Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian to discuss a new defense contract.

Last month, France sealed a $1.49 billion deal to overhaul Saudi ships and tankers and is discussing the sale of anti-aircraft missiles to Kingdom and fighter jets to Qatar. Also, last July, France signed a deal to provide the UAE anti-aircraft radar and spy satellites.

Most recently, the BBC reported that Riyadh has invested in Pakistani nuclear weapons projects and could get these bombs “at will” from Islamabad. Saudi Arabia, which signed the nuclear non-proliferation treaty and advocates a nuclear-free Middle East, has often said that if Iran reaches nuclear weapons capability, it will pursue its own nuclear deterrent.

For its part, Iran this week signed a joint statement with the IAEA that will allow nuclear inspectors to visit key nuclear sites such as the Arak nuclear reactor and the country’s main Gchine uranium mine in Bandar Abbas.

And in what is being seen as a boost for both the Iran and U.S. diplomats who need concessions from Iran to move the talks forward, the IAEA Thursday released its quarterly report on Iran, which shows Iran has dramatically slowed enrichment since electing Hassan Rouhani president. It also reports Iran has frozen construction of the contentious Arak reactor.


Related Articles:

Concern about Arak Heavy Water Research Reactor: Just an Excuse or a Reality?

- In this article, the author aims to answer the simple, but very important question that whether Iran's nuclear plant in Arak should be a cause of concern for the Western states. The Arak plant is located close to the city of Arak, some 290 km southwest of the capital city, Tehran. It is among 17 nuclear sites that Iran is currently operating under the supervision of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). -Hassan Beheshtipour 11/16/13

Israel urges France to stand firm against Iran

- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has urged France not to soften its stance towards Iran in the upcoming talks between the Islamic Republic and the six major world powers over Tehran's nuclear energy program. 11/16/13

Progress in Iran Nuclear Talks Makes Some US Allies Nervous

- Both the Arabs and the Israelis chafe at the fact that they are not in the room in Geneva negotiating alongside the United States, the five permanent members of the UN Security Council and Germany (the P5+1). Even within this grouping - a legacy of the days when the U.S. and Iran did not meet alone -- cracks have appeared that reflect irritation with U.S. policies. -Barbara Slavin 11/16/13

Nuclear watchdog reports Iranian progress

- In its latest report, the IAEA announced that Iran has halted the expansion of its uranium-enrichment facilities.In its first report since August, when Iranian President Hassan Rohani took over the administration, the International Atomic Energy Agency indicates that no new centrifuges were installed at the Fordo nuclear plant. 11/16/13

Scuppered Iran Deal Faces Scrutiny in Congress

- The anticipated agreement over Iran's controversial nuclear programme that seemed to slip away in the last stage of talks in Geneva last week is now being hotly debated on Capitol Hill. "Right now Congress is looking at the deal that wasn't and trying to figure out if it could be good enough to support," Joel Rubin, who heads policy and government affairs at the Ploughshares Fund, told IPS. -Jasmin Ramsey 11/15/13

France, Iran and the Lubricated Geneva Talks

- Negotiation, as the French writer Marquis de Sade once said, "like certain portions of the anatomy, always runs more smoothly when lubricated." In the most recent session with Iran in Geneva, the lubricant was strikingly effective. -Ali Reza Eshraghi, LobLog - 11/14/13

Diplomatic Blunders Endanger Victory with Iran in Geneva

- "Victory has a thousand fathers; defeat is an orphan" - John Kennedy's pithy phrase also has its opposite. We have seen this since last weekend's failed effort to reach an accord on nuclear matters between Iran and the so-called "P5+1", the five permanent members of the UN Security Council plus Germany. -Robert E. Hunter, LobeLog - 11/13/13

Iran Offers More Access to UN's Nuclear Watchdog

- The spokesman for Iran's nuclear department tells the official IRNA news agency Tehran is willing to grant the U.N. International Atomic Energy Agency access to its Arak reactor before the next round of talks with the agency on December 11.But Behrouz Kamalvandi also says details of such an inspection still need to be worked out. - 11/13/13

Iran Looks Toward the United States

- In fact, after over 30 years of deep distrust the stars may be aligned between the West and Iran to start the long and very difficult process of normalizing relations. The new Iranian team, with the support of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and, so far, Iran's security organizations, has moved quickly on a number of fronts to see whether a nuclear agreement is possible. -Charles Naas - 11/12/13

Kerry Pushes Back Against Israeli Criticism of Iran Nuclear Talks

- U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry is pushing back against Israeli criticism of a still-developing deal to limit Iran's nuclear program, saying the international community is not giving up anything by talking to Tehran's new leaders. -Scott Stearns, VOA - 11/12/13

France Turns Into the Top Subject on the Internet: Insults, Descriptions, the Baguette and the Peugeot

- Millions of Iranians, inside and outside the country, and even some peace-loving people around the world, stayed up on Saturday night in expectation of the news of the resolution of one of the most difficult international problems of recent years: Iran's nuclear issue. -Behrouz Samadbeighi, Rooz - 11/11/13

Israeli Intelligence Sources Contradict Bibi, Congress on Iran

- For months, top Israeli intelligence sources have been providing Prime Minister Benjamin "Bibi" Netanyahu with assessments that ought to make him welcome the progress being made at the most recent negotiations in Geneva, instead of, as one prominent Israeli journalist put it, a "party-pooper." -Marsha B. Cohen - 11/11/13

... Payvand News - 11/17/13 ... --



comments powered by Disqus

© Copyright 2013 NetNative
(All Rights Reserved)

Popular Now

Join Payvand's Facebook Page

join Payvand's daily News mailing list
* indicates required

Home | Contact | About | Archive | Web Sites | Bookstore | Persian Calendar | twitter | facebook | RSS Feed